Trading One's Eggs for a Service Discount Raises Tough Issues, Says Ethicist

This transcript has been edited for clarity.

Hi. I'm Art Caplan. I'm at the Division of Medical Ethics at NYU Grossman School of Medicine in New York City.

I had a case come to me of a 32-year-old resident who works in a hospital near where I am and was very interested in freezing her eggs. She wasn't married and was getting worried that maybe she wouldn't have a partner soon. She was also getting worried that the potential ability of her eggs to be fertilized would begin to decline, which is a phenomenon that does occur with age. She thought, I'm 32; maybe I should freeze my eggs now, as it's better than to try freezing them when I'm 35 or 37. The potency may be far less.

There are many programs out there now. There have been academic programs for a long time that have been doing egg freezing, and there are many children who have been born successfully. However, it's also true that people freeze their eggs when they're 40 years old, and the likelihood of their "working," if you will, is far less. I wouldn't say it's impossible, but age matters. This medical resident knew that and she decided to look into egg freezing.