What an AR-15 Does to a Child's Body: A Surgeon's View
This site is intended for healthcare professionals

COMMENTARY

What an AR-15 Does to a Child's Body: Why Surgeons Can't Look Away

Robert D. Glatter, MD; Joseph V. Sakran, MD, MPA, MPH; Andre Campbell, MD; Linda A. Dultz, MD, MPH

Disclosures

June 02, 2022

486

This discussion was recorded on May 27, 2022. This transcript has been edited for clarity.

Robert D. Glatter, MD: Hi. I'm Dr Robert Glatter, medical advisor for Medscape Emergency Medicine. Today we have a distinguished panel joining us to discuss the horrific mass shooting that occurred recently in Uvalde, Texas, at Robb Elementary School that killed 19 children, along with two teachers.

This is the 27th school shooting this year. An 18-year-old male armed with an AR-15 was able to enter a classroom, barricade himself for reportedly 40 minutes, and unleash unimaginable terror, forever destroying precious lives and families for generations to come.

Joining me to discuss the recent shooting is Dr Joseph Sakran, director of emergency general surgery at Johns Hopkins Hospital and a survivor of gun violence himself; Dr Linda Dultz, a trauma surgeon at UT Southwestern Medical Center; and finally, Dr Andre Campbell, attending trauma surgeon at Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital.

Thank you, everyone, for taking this time to join me on such an important topic. I really appreciate it.

Joseph V. Sakran, MD, MPA, MPH: Thanks for having us, Robert.

Andre Campbell, MD: Thank you.

Glatter: Let's talk about the mechanics of the AR-15 (ArmaLite AR-15) and how this compares with a typical 9-mm handgun (or even a standard rifle or shotgun, for that matter). Joe, can you talk about the injuries and what you see in the ED as opposed to the operating room?

Sakran: I just want to first say that I think I speak on behalf of all Americans when I say that we just woke up this past week, once again, feeling absolutely terrible after yet another horrific and senseless tragedy. We continue to wake up time and time again and hear about the slaughter of children in elementary schools and the slaughter of community members in grocery stores, at the synagogue, and at concerts.

I just refuse to believe that this is the best that we can do. I'm saddened and heartbroken, but I'm also angry. I know we're going to have time to discuss this, but I just can't start without underscoring the importance that we all have to play a role in ensuring that our communities are safer.

When you look at the mass shootings that happen and the use of the AR-15, a weapon of war and a military-style assault weapon, it is very clear that these weapons allow gunmen not only to fire numerous rounds quickly but also to create significant damage because they travel at more than 3000 feet per second. When that happens, a couple of different things take place. The first is you have what's called the permanent cavity that's dependent upon the size of the bullet. Then you have this temporary cavity that's created, which essentially is dependent on the velocity, or how fast this bullet is traveling.

If you think about a boat that's traveling, it has this wake that results behind it. That's the temporary cavity that is created. The faster the boat travels, the larger that wake is. The same thing is happening in the human body, where you get this energy that is dissipated across a path that then results in destruction. The destruction is very dependent upon whether you hit a main vessel, a bone, or a vital organ. It is very different than what we see with a handgun.

Glatter: You're essentially talking about the ability to survive a wound from an AR-15 vs a 9-mm handgun, for example. That really is what this comes down to. If you were shot with one of the two weapons, your chances of surviving would be quite different.

Dr Campbell, I want to hear about your experience with what you have seen from wounds from these assault weapons in San Francisco.

Campbell: Thank you, Dr Glatter, for having me on this morning. I just want to echo some of what my good friend and colleague, Dr Sakran, just said.

Our hearts are heavy over what has happened. It is just devastating. I think many of us who care for these patients all the time are sick and tired of being sick and tired. We have been through this, and it seems like it's just a bad dream that repeats itself, and the casualties are just catastrophic. You would think that 10 years after we had the tragedy at Sandy Hook, with 20 children and five teachers, now 19 children and two teachers [at Robb Elementary]… but there are other casualties, too.

I just want to highlight that the husband of one of the victims recently died because he was so overwhelmed. We're going to talk about the physics and the energy and dissipation of bullets, but these are people. The families are ruined. They're destroyed. And they will never be the same. I think that we should just sit there and ruminate on that first, on what is going on. We need to have a national reckoning, and we'll get into that later.

Extent of the Gunshot Injuries From Military-Style Rifles

Campbell: A little bit about bullets and what they do. The bigger bullets travel faster in AR-15s. When I first started surgeries way back when, we had "Saturday night specials," which were 22-caliber bullets, where people got shot, and depending on where you're shot, it could cause catastrophe. Then it became 40-mm, and AR-15, and AK-47, and Uzi submachine guns, and high-capacity rifles. The faster a bullet hits, the more destruction it has. It's traveling at 2000 or 3000 miles an hour. It's really fast; the bullets bounce and explode.

Just for the regular folks who may not be medically inclined, it causes an explosion in the human body where it hits bone, blood vessels, nerves, and skin. It's a devastating injury when that happens. We've all seen simulations of what these bullets can do. Certainly, you can get a shot with a 40-caliber pistol and have devastating injuries.

It's all about where you're shot, what happens after you get shot, whether it's a glancing blow or it's a full-on devastating explosion that happens in the human body — whether it's the thorax, the head, or extremities. If it's the extremities, you may have a shot at trying to save the patient, which is why we've promoted many things that we'll talk about later on. But it's just devastating, unbelievable destruction.

It's minutes before the patients bleed out, so you have to act fast. That's why at trauma centers — we work at level 1 trauma centers — we get the patients there early, we try to get them in the operating room, and our job is to find a way to stop bleeding. We've gotten pretty good at that. Now, we can save many people, but we can't save everybody.

We're out here every day trying to save people and get them back to their families because that's what we do as trauma surgeons. We come in, we save people's lives, and we work in concert with pre-hospital staff, our emergency physicians, and the trauma center to make things happen. I'll just start with that utter devastation, exploding, and the terrible things that happen to people when they are the target of these weapons of mass destruction.

Glatter: That's a very graphic and accurate description. Dr Dultz, if you do survive one of these types of injuries, there is the risk of complications, such as fistulas, wound infections, prolonged hospital stays, and the need for long-term care. You are an expert, working in the surgical ICU at your facility. These are the wounds of war that are in the ICU. These patients have prolonged stays. Can you comment about what you're seeing regarding healing, complications, and so forth?

Linda A. Dultz, MD, MPH: Thank you very much for allowing me to talk on this important topic. I greatly appreciate that. For us working in the trauma bay and in the ICU, we see these devastating injuries. Obviously, the more bullets, the type of bullet, the level of destruction, the more devastating of an injury that patient will have that will lead to their prolonged complication and ICU courses. I think the bigger picture is what we don't see, such as the long, drawn-out PTSD and the mental rehabilitation that comes from that.

It's not just a physical issue. It's emotional, and one that leads to a lower quality of life and long-term disability for these patients. That's where some of our research is focusing on as well — it's not just the physical aspect, because that's going to happen and we will get our patients through that and we will get them home, hopefully, and back to their families. That long-term effect, though, for most people, will never go away. We're focusing on that right now and a large amount of research is being put into that.

It's a Long Road to Recovery: Recidivism and Intervention Programs

Glatter: That's an important point you draw upon because as soon as a trauma develops in some institutions, there's a team approach involving crisis counselors and social workers right in the trauma bays, at least for some of my colleagues. It doesn't start once they hit the floor or after they've been out of the ICU - it's immediate.

Dr Sakran and Dr Campbell, is it an all-inclusive approach? It starts immediately that you engage the patient, the family, and resources that are available. This is going to be a long, drawn-out course.

Sakran: What Dr Dultz said was spot-on. For every death, you have about two to three people that are nonfatally injured — and those are conservative numbers.

  • 486

Comments

3090D553-9492-4563-8681-AD288FA52ACE
Comments on Medscape are moderated and should be professional in tone and on topic. You must declare any conflicts of interest related to your comments and responses. Please see our Commenting Guide for further information. We reserve the right to remove posts at our sole discretion.

processing....

Medscape

Log in or register for free to unlock more Medscape content

Unlimited access to our entire network of sites and services